Showing posts with label Ratan Tata. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Ratan Tata. Show all posts

Monday, 8 April 2019

Tata Tapes Controversy - illegal Tapping of Phone Calls of Nusli Wadia



A big political scandal in India took place in the 1990s that involved the owners of a company called Tata Tea, terrorist group ULFA (United Liberation Front of Assam), and the Assam government.  Prafulla Kumar Mahanta, the then Chief Minister of Assam alleged that Tata Tea was involved in conduct deemed anti-national. 

The situation came to light when a journalist for Indian Express, Ritu Sarin, published a story regarding illegal tapping of phone calls of Nusli Wadia, a business tycoon.    The transcripts were published and involved a number of high profile individuals, including a Rajya Sabha Member of Parliament, and Ratan Tata.



The History Behind the Controversy

It was during the 1990s that the ULFA, a banned terror group, had been very active in the Assam area.  The group had been extorting funds from tea companies as a means of funding their activities.  Fear made most of the tea companies pay the ULFA, however, Tata Tea refused.  In 1997, ULFA was responsible for a number of militant activities and terror attacks.  One such attack was the failed attempt at an assassination against the Chief Minister who headed the Assam government, Prafulla Kumar Mahanta.  It brought publicity to the breaking down of law and order of the Assam region, which negatively impacted the Mahanta government.  It was during similar circumstances in 1990 that his previous government was dismissed.  



Mahanta visited Calcutta to raise funding for his party before the assembly elections but did not get a good response from the tea companies, more importantly from Tata Tea, who refused to pay anything.

In August of 1997 an ULFA member, Pranati Deka, was arrested, along with her baby and two others.  They found a visiting card on one of the accomplices belonging to one of Tata Tea's senior executives, Brojen Gogoi.  It was reported that he had gone with Deka to Mumbai for her to give birth and cover her medical costs and lodgings.  Tata Tea had paid INR 50,000 and claimed it had not been aware of Deka's link to the ULFA.



Tata Tea top officials were interrogated by the Assam police, leading to the arrest of General Manager, SS Dogra under the charge of aiding and abetting ULFA in their unlawful activities.  Gogoi was also wanted for questioning but authorities were unable to arrest him at the time.  He was reported to have been abroad studying, however, reports claimed he was using a guest house in India to avoid the police.  It wasn't until September that he turned himself in.

The Tata Tapes

The Tata tapes held conversations that took place between Nusli Wadia and a number of powerful industrial and political individuals.  The tapes proved that the Tatas were attempting to coerce the central government to step in to deal with the issues they were having with the Assam government.  It was also suggested that the Tatas were aware of Gogoi's whereabouts and had lied to the Assam government when questioned. 



The mystery in this situation is who actually tapped Wadia's phones,  The Central Government denied that it was them, and a probe was launched to find out who was responsible for infringing on these individual's privacy. 

The controversy brought to light what the Assam tea industry was dealing with for the past two decades, grabbing the attention of the entire country.  The industry had been putting up with extortion, kidnapping, and murder by militants of both the ULFA and NDFB (National Democratic Front of Bodoland). 


References:


1. http://indiatodaygroup.com/itoday/20101997/cov.html
2. http://www.india-today.com/btoday/22101997/tata.html
3. http://www.rediff.com/news/oct/13assam.htm
4. http://www.rediff.com/business/sep/15tata.htm
5. http://www.rediff.com/business/sep/16assam.htm
6.https://web.archive.org/web/19971007063854/http://www.expressindia.com:80/ie/daily/19971007/28050903.html
7.https://web.archive.org/web/19971023074806/http://www.expressindia.com:80/ie/daily/19971006/27950853.html

Radia Tapes Controversy - How one women controlled entire government policy in India through sexual favours



The Radia Tapes Controversy (also known as the 2G Spectrum Scam) is one of the Scandals of India took place between 2008 and 2009.  It involved political lobbyist, Nira Radia of Vaishnavi Communications, and several of her media friends, such as Vir Sanghvi, Hindustan Times' editorial director, and Barkha Dutt, the group editor of NDTV.   In these tapes, they are heard making promises to Radia, her political friends, and her corporate clients.  The tapes show how one woman attempted to influence government policy via the control of journalists and politicians, how she destroyed careers and reputations.



During a one year period, the Home Ministry gave the Indian Income Tax Department to go-ahead to tap Radia's phones.  It was part of their ongoing investigation into the possibility of money laundering, tax evasion, financial practices that were restricted.  The decision was made after finance ministry had received an anonymous letter claiming Radia was a covert operator to a foreign government. 



One question that was asked was, why was this particular anonymous letter taken so seriously?  And how did it make it's way to the ministry's highest levels?  It is believed that the letter came from a powerful organization that was known to some of the ministry's important people. 

It was in 2010 that a magazine called OPEN published a story that included transcripts from some of these conversations between Radia and others involved, where Radia attempted to make deals related to the 2G Spectrum Allocation.  Radia attempted to use people from the media to influence the decision of having A. Raja appointed as the telecom minister.  Radia influenced news reports and Parliament discussion at the request of corporate houses.



The Motive Behind The Scandal

The motive here was the abuse of power by one small group of very powerful people within the public sector; politicians, journalists, and businessman.  This group attempted to subvert the democratic system for their own benefit and interests.

Those involved tried to claim it was a breach of privacy, being tapped secretly.  However, the argument is that it involved public interests, therefore the public should be made aware of what was going on.  The media felt they had an obligation to report this to the public and their fundamental rights for freedom of speech.  At one point, a media blackout that banned the publishing of the tapes would have defeated both freedoms of expression and public interest just to save the privacy of a small powerful, but a corrupt group of people trying to manipulate the system.



One main player who tried to prevent publication of these transcripts was Ratan Tata, an Indian industrialist.  However, it was felt that the conversations revealed a number of immoral and illegal acts that the public had a right to know about.  The strange part is that, where other people's reputations and careers were ruined, Tata emerged from the incident with barely a scratch to his, even though he was heard on these tapes trying to manipulate policy.



It was reported that only 100 out of 5,800 tapped conversations had been made public and these were enough to reveal how India was being run, the subservience of politicians, how court decisions can be fixed, how MP's will lobby for big business houses, and that everything in the country is managed by corporate.

References

1. http://expressbuzz.com/nation/radia-tapes-featuring-senior-scribes-create-stir/224516.html
2. http://business-standard.com/india/news/radia-shuts-vaishnavi/454061/
3. https://www.ibtimes.com/indian-medias-mighty-stand-exposed-wrong-side-2g-spectrum-scam-248166
4. http://www.zeenews.com/news670068.html
5. http://news.in.msn.com/national/article.aspx?cp-documentid=4595860
6. http://news.oneindia.in/2010/11/21/does-media-follow-unethical-biased-journalism.html
7.http://indiatoday.intoday.in/site/Story/96109/Top%20Stories/%27Radia+lobbied+to+get+Raja+telecom+ministry%27.html
8. http://www.openthemagazine.com/article/nation/some-telephone-conversations
9. http://www.tehelka.com/story_main47.asp?filename=Ws1911102G_FALLOUT.asp
10. http://www.dnaindia.com/india/report_leaked-tapes-cbi-says-it-has-5851-recordings_1470650
11. http://indiatoday.intoday.in/site/Story/120849/India/jpc-on-radia-tapes.html
12. http://www.mid-day.com/news/2010/apr/290410-india-inc-tapped-phone-tapping-leaked-report-ratan-tata-mukesh-ambani-sunil-mittal.htm
13. http://www.outlookindia.com/article.aspx?268071
14. http://business.outlookindia.com/view.aspx?vname=IMP-Prabhu%20Chawla%20Gas%20judgement%20discussion-20090620-143207.wav
15. http://www.dnaindia.com/blogs/post.php?postid=318
16. http://openthemagazine.com/article/nation/i-am-there-you-want-me-to-speak-to-anyone
17. http://www.outlookindia.com/magazine/story/favourite-lobby-horses/265345
18. http://business.outlookindia.com/view.aspx?vname=Barkha--18-188819-0-10-20090522-094851.wav
19. http://business.outlookindia.com/view.aspx?vname=Barkha%20Dutt-02-188819-0-01-20090522-104733.wav
20. http://www.dnaindia.com/india/report_barkhagate-protests-in-140-characters-leave-no-space-for-gray-areas_1471128